A boat, a pair of keys, a hand pulled back in fear. Painters often tell the story of Saint Peter through an ordinary object or a single gesture. In Caravaggio’s Denial, hands almost replace dialogue. In Rembrandt, a distant glance supplies the detail that changes the entire scene.
These ten paintings follow Peter from the shores of Galilee to his traditional martyrdom and show how the same apostle could be the subject of both an intimate portrait and a monumental altarpiece.
From fisherman to apostle
Matthew 4:18–22 describes Jesus calling the brothers Simon Peter and Andrew as they fish. In Matthew 16:13–20, Jesus speaks of the keys of the kingdom of heaven after Peter names him as the Messiah. The third widely painted episode occurs after Jesus’ arrest. Peter denies knowing him, then recognizes what he has done when the cock crows.
The keys tend to identify Peter in devotional portraits, while a boat or a gathering around a fire helps place him in a particular Gospel story. An inverted cross belongs to the subsequent tradition about his death. Each visual clue changes how you read the same face.
1. The Calling of Saints Peter and Andrew · Gentile da Fabriano

The shoreline makes the Gospel story recognizable before the viewer identifies individual faces. Look at the relation between the men, their boat, and the figure who calls them. The fishing setting gives the change in their lives a concrete starting point.
View this reproduction → →2. The Calling of Saints Peter and Andrew · Caravaggio

The Royal Collection identifies this work as Caravaggio’s. He brings the figures close to the surface, where an exchange of gestures carries the story. The interruption of ordinary work feels immediate, even without the broad landscape used in many earlier versions.
View this reproduction → →3. Saint Peter Finding the Tribute Money · Peter Paul Rubens

Matthew 17:24–27 describes Peter finding a coin in the mouth of a fish to pay the temple tax. The scene returns the apostle to his familiar world of fishing. Look for the work of the hands and the low point of attention, as an apparently ordinary task takes on narrative significance.
View this reproduction → →4. Saint Peter · Fra Filippo Lippi

A single saint can carry the identity of an entire chapter of the Gospel. Study the treatment of Peter’s head and the relationship between his face and his attributes. A figure designed for sustained recognition asks for a different pace of looking from the crowded narrative scenes.
View this reproduction → →5. Saints Peter and Paul · Carlo Crivelli

Peter and Paul are often paired as apostles with distinct missions. Look for how the painting makes the saints identifiable through dress, posture and attributes. The traditional symbols of keys and sword can be read together as a compact introduction to the two figures.
View this reproduction → →6. Saint Peter · Peter Paul Rubens

The physical presence of the apostle is the point of this portrait. Compare the modeling of his features and the weight of the folds with the harder outlines of earlier panels. At close range, Rubens gives a familiar figure the energy of a person who has just turned toward us.
View this reproduction → →7. The Denial of Saint Peter · Caravaggio

The hands do much of the storytelling. The Metropolitan Museum of Art relates the accusing fingers to Peter’s three denials. Peter’s own hands turn the movement back toward his chest. Concentrated illumination leaves enough detail to follow the exchange across the darkness.
View this reproduction → →8. The Denial of Saint Peter · Georges de La Tour

The candle lets the denial unfold alongside a game of dice. Start with what is immediately visible in the pool of light, then find the exchange that gives the painting its title. The effect is a courtyard busy with its own business, where Peter’s choice happens at the edge of other people’s attention.
View this reproduction → →9. The Denial of Saint Peter · Rembrandt

The figures in the foreground draw attention, but there is a second encounter at a distance. Jesus is visible farther back, turning toward Peter. That quieter detail changes the emotional scale of the episode and recalls the moment when their eyes meet in Luke 22:61.
View this reproduction → →10. The Crucifixion of Saint Peter · Peter Paul Rubens

In the tradition of Peter’s martyrdom, the apostle is crucified upside down. Rubens organizes the altarpiece around the effort of raising the cross. Trace the strong diagonals and then locate Peter’s face. The composition keeps a single person visible inside a scene built from muscular movement.
View this reproduction → →Compare three paintings of the Denial
Caravaggio makes the accusation feel immediate by moving the figures near the viewer. Georges de La Tour lets the story share a room with dice players and candlelight. Rembrandt asks you to look into the distance for Jesus’ response. Viewed together, the paintings show three decisions an artist can make about the same passage: where to put the light, how much of the surrounding world to show, and when to let another figure answer Peter’s gesture.
Further reading
- Matthew 16 · Peter and the keys
- Luke 22 · Peter’s denial
- The Met · Caravaggio’s Denial of Saint Peter
- Rijksmuseum · Rembrandt’s Denial of Saint Peter
- Royal Collection · The Calling of Saints Peter and Andrew
- Saint Francis of Assisi in historical art